Who needs thrusters

Shel,
You are right! I hear people all the time say they dont want to go out today because it is to windy, may rain, tide is to low or to high etc etc. Those people wont be in boating very long. They will also try and justify the expense and decide it is not worth it. The truth is they are extremely nervous to move. My feeling is that they need to get involved and hang with those who know more then they do so they can learn. As in this website most boaters are very willing to share and help those who do not have the experience. Even if you are experience there is allot to learn. The advice given in this topic can help people get out on the water without fear.
 
I get a certain feeling of pride being able to put her in where she just fits. About two months ago, I put all 41 feet of her into a spot that was less than 43 feet, with boats in front and back. Wind was off the dock, which helped, but using just spring lines and motors, with the assistance of a very good Admiral, she slid right in there like a glove. The guys in front and behind looked like they were going to poop themselves as I was coming in, but afterwards it was all "nice job, Cap", "Great docking" etc, which was kinda cool.
 
jmicklov

My boat will walk sideways. It doesn't work in wind or current docking situations. I don't find this skill being used very often due to my desire to use a docking plan that I can rely upon.

Shel

You have a great attitude!

I would consider backing into your slip. I find it works like a front wheel drive car in the snow, it pulls. Backing into the wind and using a spring lines have been a great combo for me.

To everyone:

IMO Pod drives, and thrusters have their place. If this "boat handling concern" is a barrier to people buying and using boats I am happy to see this change in the market place.
 
quote:

Originally posted by millsan1

I get a certain feeling of pride being able to put her in where she just fits. About two months ago, I put all 41 feet of her into a spot that was less than 43 feet, with boats in front and back. Wind was off the dock, which helped, but using just spring lines and motors, with the assistance of a very good Admiral, she slid right in there like a glove. The guys in front and behind looked like they were going to poop themselves as I was coming in, but afterwards it was all "nice job, Cap", "Great docking" etc, which was kinda cool.






It really does feel nice Anthony!
 
quote:

Originally posted by mrknowitall

I would consider backing into your slip.






You wouldn't if you seen it... Unless you want your props polished. :-)

Shel
 
quote:

Originally posted by Capt. Bill1

I've never seen it work with outdrives.




It sure works with the Axius system with Merc outdrives...I know, I test piloted a Maxum with the system installed.

Put both sticks in neutral, grab the little joystick, and the boat will walk exactly in the direction the stick is moved....exactly!

But with Axius, the ODs move independently of each other, which is a bit different than what most of us have [^]
 
I consider my thruster a 2nd mate. We stern into our slip and have finger on both sides. Our slip is 16' wide, while our beam is 14' and change. A tight fit. most of the time I don't need to use the thruster, but for a quick correction one way or the other its great.

I have seen too many "captains" use it continuasly to try to move a boat several feet one way or the other cause they "missed" their dock. That's when the pop the breaker which is hell and gone from the bridge.

I always said real captains don't need a thruster, but once i got one, I would not want to be without it.
 
Sorry I think I am in the minority. I have a thruster and there are times where it has been a real help. I also use it even when I don't have to. Can I dock the boat without it yes. Why? Because once I installed the grinder it gave me the confidence I didn't have before it and I wouldn't go out unless conditions were perfect. To be honest I probably might have got out of this world of boating without it. Now I have approach and abort plans and an alternate plan if the thruster fails. Many times I just tap the thruster. It came in real handy when my nervous wife got her fingers caught in the line at the bow cleat, I saw it before she could even make a sound and took the strain off of her fingers so no damage. I agree the spring line is the key to good docking and knowing how to use the shifter/throttles is best. My new approach is if I start to have problems I abort and start again works like a charm. I usually get the boat in on the 1st try. I also think the thruster is great if you have twins and lose a motor. There are too many positives vs negatives for me to not have one. After all we are not talking about the IPS system we are talking about a tool with a fairly high success rate of working when properly maintained. I test mine prior to leaving the dock and on the approach. I rarely have to use it when leaving a dock it is primarily used when docking in wind.
Bill
 
quote:

Originally posted by Maycpa

I consider my thruster a 2nd mate. We stern into our slip and have finger on both sides. Our slip is 16' wide, while our beam is 14' and change. A tight fit. most of the time I don't need to use the thruster, but for a quick correction one way or the other its great.






I'm not sure i can see how a BOW thruster helps while backing into a slip... 1 to 2' clearance it's what i'd call tight, it's unfortunately pretty common in most marinas these days.

when you back in, you need to move the stern sideways, not the bow the bow has nowhere to go but follow the stern :)

backing in, when i get to the point where the stern needs to get between the pilings, I find the only tool is the gears... it doesn't take a lot of practice to be able to move the stern a few inches each way simply by briefly bumping one gear in forward. It cuts the momentum and moves the stern sideways by whatever amount you need.

you can grind away with the BT as much as you want, it's not going to move the stern one bit!

now, if you don't have pilings you can lean on, then a BT will help you keep the bow under control and prevent it from being blow onto another boat but in the typical slip with wood piles, it's not going to help one bit fitting the stern into the slip.
 
"I consider my thruster a 2nd mate." Me too, in the bedroom :)
 
"I'm not sure i can see how a BOW thruster helps while backing into a slip... "

Won't help with putting the stern in but it might help with keeping the boat lined up in a cross-wind or current. With a "walkable" boat maybe not necessary.
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

quote:

Originally posted by Maycpa

I consider my thruster a 2nd mate. We stern into our slip and have finger on both sides. Our slip is 16' wide, while our beam is 14' and change. A tight fit. most of the time I don't need to use the thruster, but for a quick correction one way or the other its great.






I'm not sure i can see how a BOW thruster helps while backing into a slip... 1 to 2' clearance it's what i'd call tight, it's unfortunately pretty common in most marinas these days.

when you back in, you need to move the stern sideways, not the bow the bow has nowhere to go but follow the stern :)

backing in, when i get to the point where the stern needs to get between the pilings, I find the only tool is the gears... it doesn't take a lot of practice to be able to move the stern a few inches each way simply by briefly bumping one gear in forward. It cuts the momentum and moves the stern sideways by whatever amount you need.

you can grind away with the BT as much as you want, it's not going to move the stern one bit!

now, if you don't have pilings you can lean on, then a BT will help you keep the bow under control and prevent it from being blow onto another boat but in the typical slip with wood piles, it's not going to help one bit fitting the stern into the slip.








Lot of good info in this thread concerning docking but I have to disagree concerning the stern not moving when using the BT, If I move my toggle to bring the bow to port my stern will move oposite. Might be boat design but in my case it does.
 
I think it would in most cases; generally with twins the engines would be used to control the stern but everything interacts.
 
well, everything affect everything however it's much quicker and much more efficient to put one engine in FWD for a second if you need to line up the stern with the slip than using the BT... as you back in, let say you're a little too far to port, if you bump the stbd engine in fwd for a sec, your stern will move to stbd. the larger, torquier, the engines (and prop) the shorter the impulse. With a gas boat or a trawler with small engine, you may need to bump the RPM a bit too... on a larger boat, i barely stay in gear, it's just a bump in and out.

using the gears not only means you will move the stern but that you will also slow the boat, which you need to if you're not lined up perfectly. And if you use the BT, you will push the bow out of wack, so why bother. let say you're backing in with the wind on your stbd side, chances are you're going to end up a little to port and will need to bring the stern back to stbd to clear the piling. If you have to use opposite BT to move the stern, you're going to have to grind the bow even further to port to bring the stern back to stbd! that means the boat is now coming in at an angle which makes it even wider at the stern and further reduce your clearnance. so in this example, if you going to use the BT, it's going to bring the bow back upwind, to stbd, which will push the stern further away to port. That's why I focus on the gears and not the BT unless I really have too. for instance, with that strong Xwind once i have the stern between the pilings i may use the BT reduce the rubbing against the piling. Or I just stop the boat with the stern between the pilings and pivot agaisnt the port piling to bring the stern back up. it's just as easy.

If you use the BT to attempt to move the stern, in addition to the delayed reaction, you still need to slow the boat... In fact, I find myself using the gear to line up, even with stern thruster! again, i'd have to slow or stop the boat anyway, so way bother letting go of the engine controls to mess with the joystick?

obviously I'm talking about tight slips, with under a foot clearance, where you will have to correct as your stern is within a few feet of the entrance. If the slip is wide, over 2' clearance, it really doens't matter.
 
icon_speech_no.gif
The original post is wrong. The maneuver as described will move your boat to Starboard not Port.
In theory the bow goes the direction of the reversed prop and the stern goes in the direction of the rudders with forward prop.
 
Just to reinforce the "each boat is different" point, this technique in and of itself doesn't work on my Hatt. The engines and props just have too much torque to leave the shifters split. I have used, in calm conditions, a variation of this technique, in fact I had to frequently this past winter due to the unusual shape of the slip we had along a concrete seawall at the end of a fairway. This involved turning the wheel all the way over away from the dock, and shifting the outside engine in and out of gear, occasionally bumping the inside engine into forward to adjust if need be. Like I said, works on my boat..

Oh, and I do have a bow thruster, which came in handy when I remembered to use it. I learned how to operate a twin on boats without thrusters, and I forget to use it sometimes.. too much stuff to keep track of! If anything, I don't use it enough as it is a great tool in many situations. I have had a couple of occasions where very experienced professional captains handled the boat, and they each jumped on those thruster buttons like excited Jeopardy contestants. As one said, "H--- yeah, I use it, it's the way best thing for what we had to do there!" Also, I have had to dock a twin on one engine a few times, each in tight spots. Once on a boat (43 Mainship "Trawler") without a thruster and once on this boat. Having the thruster sure made it a lot less stressful, especially getting off the dock.

George
Hatteras 56MY
 
Well, I never got to try out the maneuver this weekend. Even though we went out on Saturday, the river was still running like a banshee (from all the rain), and the wind was blowing at least 25 mph. In this case, it's back down a little past the spot and come into the dock at a good angle with more power too. No time for finesse.
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

quote:

Originally posted by Maycpa

I consider my thruster a 2nd mate. We stern into our slip and have finger on both sides. Our slip is 16' wide, while our beam is 14' and change. A tight fit. most of the time I don't need to use the thruster, but for a quick correction one way or the other its great.






I'm not sure i can see how a BOW thruster helps while backing into a slip... 1 to 2' clearance it's what i'd call tight, it's unfortunately pretty common in most marinas these days.

when you back in, you need to move the stern sideways, not the bow the bow has nowhere to go but follow the stern :)

backing in, when i get to the point where the stern needs to get between the pilings, I find the only tool is the gears... it doesn't take a lot of practice to be able to move the stern a few inches each way simply by briefly bumping one gear in forward. It cuts the momentum and moves the stern sideways by whatever amount you need.

you can grind away with the BT as much as you want, it's not going to move the stern one bit!

now, if you don't have pilings you can lean on, then a BT will help you keep the bow under control and prevent it from being blow onto another boat but in the typical slip with wood piles, it's not going to help one bit fitting the stern into the slip.








We don't have piles, we have dock fingers and it allows me to straighten up the front as we stern into the slip.
 
Back
Top