Who needs thrusters

I "walk" boats all the time, no problem at least 55 ft. and under, I know will walk them all the time.
 
Great feedback folks. I don't have any plans on getting thrusters. Like you said, if you can't learn how your boat handles and what you're supposed to do, probably don't belong in a boat. I've gotten a lot more confidence over the past few years learning fine maneuvering skills and can handle most any condition. The majority of my boating is in a river (which is also tidal), and constantly dealing with wind and/or currents. This is why I seldom go out solo
:-(. The problem I'd have with Pascal's approach is my mid-ship cleat is not easily accessible and I'd have to use a boat hook to get the spring line onto the dock cleat.
When coming into my dock, I'd have a better chance of tying up the stern line to the dock first, since I can get to in much quicker, then grab the spring line or bow line and get onto the dock and secure the bow before it starts to walk away from the dock b/c of wind and/or current.

Outside of 'moving the boat sideways' as posed in the original question, 'crabbing' the boat has also proven very effective for me also, using the port or stbd shifter alternately between forward and reverse for getting into the dock. I'll also report back if my boat (also with small rudders and 17" props)can move sideways.

It's great to hear how some of you folks handle different conditions. The day I stop learning is the day I stop boating as well. Thanks for all the feedback.
 
ghost

the reason why i prefer to have the eye on the boat cleat is that i never know if there will be people on the dock to catch the line... I find it easier to throw the bight of the line on the dock behind the cleat, then pull on the bitter end so that the bight catches the cleat, then tie the bitter end back on the boat.

once that's done, I'm home. literally speaking.

trying to pass the eye on a dockside cleat when you're 5 or 6' high, doens't work very well, at least for me... maybe i need to try it more often.

two incidents I witnessed...
my neighbor coming back in with a twin engine trawler, hit me coming bow in while trying to use the coffee grinder to turn the boat into the slip... no big deal, bent a stanchion and cracked the teak rail, easy repair, he's a real nice guy...

a 40ish express with bow thruster rubbing and damaging two boats while trying to leave a dock where he was pinned by the wind... he grinded away but never cleared the other guys.

with an express, it can be indeed hard to get to the midship cleat, in that case, using an aft spring tied to a stern cleat, and reversing on it might work better.
 
Backing down on an after spring works very well on my single.
 
My crew is eager to learn and getting better all the time, but I like having the ability to maneuver by myself. My boat will "walk" sideways very well. The danger is becoming dependent on a bow thruster that might not be there when you need it most. It is an electrical device on a boat. It is inherently unreliable. It is a game I play to try and do all the maneuvering without the bow thruster and only use it when I really have to.
 
"indeed hard to get to the midship cleat, in that case, using an aft spring tied to a stern cleat, and reversing on it might work better."

I use the "pascal method" successfully most of the time. I've got the same conditions as Jack - evil current and an always present wind coming from many directions. With an incoming tide and the wind coming from the stern, I glide past my dock like I'm still in gear - when I'm not. Sometimes backing down is the only option. Then a quick tie-up off the bow or midship is key 'cause if a broadside wind catches the bow, I'm off to the races all over again.
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

ghost

the reason why i prefer to have the eye on the boat cleat is that i never know if there will be people on the dock to catch the line... I find it easier to throw the bight of the line on the dock behind the cleat, then pull on the bitter end so that the bight catches the cleat, then tie the bitter end back on the boat.

once that's done, I'm home. literally speaking.

trying to pass the eye on a dockside cleat when you're 5 or 6' high, doens't work very well, at least for me... maybe i need to try it more often.

two incidents I witnessed...
my neighbor coming back in with a twin engine trawler, hit me coming bow in while trying to use the coffee grinder to turn the boat into the slip... no big deal, bent a stanchion and cracked the teak rail, easy repair, he's a real nice guy...

a 40ish express with bow thruster rubbing and damaging two boats while trying to leave a dock where he was pinned by the wind... he grinded away but never cleared the other guys.

with an express, it can be indeed hard to get to the midship cleat, in that case, using an aft spring tied to a stern cleat, and reversing on it might work better.






I prefer the eye on the boat cleat for two reasons:

1) It ensures that I do not/cannot back down too far, which is especially handy when I am alone

2) I find it easier to grab from the dock to the boat. When I untie, I run the spring line forward on the dock and leave it where it can easily be grabbed from the boat.
 
that said, since we're on the subject of lines and eye vs bitter end, the springs are the only lines for which i use the eye on the boat cleats. for the bow and stern lines, i put the eye on the dock (cleat or pilings) and use the bitter end on the boat, marked by a zip tie where it crosses the chocks. This lets me work the line on the cleat instead of having to pull on the eye with no leverage.

that's obviously less important with smaller boats but as boats get larger, it's increasingly difficult to pull them agaisnt the wind and strugling to put an eye on the cleat can results in fingers caught between the eye and the cleat...
 
This conversation about docking with spring lines is very interesting. I am getting pretty use to docking in calm to moderate winds, minor current, with just the shifters. I have not delved into using the rudders for docking yet, but will try to see if my boat can walk sideways this weekend.

I did have a difficult situation this past weekend, when coming into my slip there was about a 20-25 knot wind coming off the dock. There is only 15-16 feet between the dock and the next boat and my boat is 12.6 feet wide, so not much room for a sharp approach. I made 3 approaches and was able to dock and maintain 100% control, but using the throttles a little more than I’d like, it didn’t look smooth. Will this spring line technique help me here? The dock is a 40 foot finger dock that has to be bow in. Obviously I have no room to swing in on a long spring line as I will take out the boat next to me. So I am trying to picture this. I have a line with the bitter end cleated to the closest cleat to me on my approach, have the eye at the end of a 15-20 foot length at a position on the dock that can be reached with a boat hook. On my approach I get close enough for a my wife to hook the eye with a boat hook from the bow and loop the eye around a midship cleat on the boat. From here, if there was no boat docked next to me I would swing in on the full length and snug up to the dock, right? If there is a boat next to me, do I have to somehow not loop the eye on the midship cleat but figure eight it and pull in the slack as I get closer to the dock, then when there is only enough length on the line to allow me to swing and clear the next boat, swing in snug to the dock, right? Is this doable or is my situation not good for the type of manoeuvre you have been talking about?
 
i dont' quite understand your set up.

you go bow in in a 15 to 16' slip, with another boat on one side and a 40' finger on the other, correct?
any piling between you and the other boat?

if that's the setup, then as you come bow in, you'd use a spring line from the end of the finger pier, to your midship cleat (the foreward most if you have 2 midship cleats). since it's your home slip you can leave it on the dock. As you come in, you pick up the line with a boat hook and put the eye on your midship cleat. power on gently forward and the when spring line will pull you alongside the finger pier, away from the other boat. I'd still use fenders on the side facing the other boats, just in case.
 
Shel:

As Pascal indicates, have a spring tied off at the end of your finger pier with the eye going to the boat. If you have a piling at the end, leave the eye of the spring looped over a hoof into the piling (easy height to grab with the pole). If the wind is blowing you off the dock and you must bow in - come in at an angle to the dock, have your grew grab the line and loop it over your midship cleat (I would be in neutral at this point). Assuming you are port side too, port engine forward to straighten out the boat. Once straight, power forward and you will come right along side the dock.

Given the 3 foot space, I would still put fneders out on both sides, but the spring and your engines will keep you off the other boat.
 
Sorry That I was unclear. Happens a lot.

All docks are 40' fingers, including mine. No pilings. I said 15-20 feet of length on the line between the cleated end on the dock and the eye, it is so I can't go any further forward than that so I don't run up on land. Plus the length would need to be that long in order to reach back to my midship cleat when picked up from the bow with a hook, wouldn't it?

I'm still confused. How will the spring line "pull" me alongside the finger dock? Once the line is hooked on my cleat, I only have any leverage when the line is tight at 15-20 feet. Once I get closer to the dock the line will slack and I will have no pull. The only thing I can see is swinging on the line like a 15' pendulum, and with the other boat in the slip, that will not be possible. I must be misunderstanding something you are saying.

Thanks,
Shel
 
i'm not sure i understand what you mean...

you want to have the spring line coming from teh outer end of the finger pier towards the bow of your boat. as you come bow in, and grab the line, it will slack. as you pull on it, it will get you alongside.

springline.gif
 
"Once I get closer to the dock the line will slack and I will have no pull. The only thing I can see is swinging on the line like a 15' pendulum, and with the other boat in the slip, that will not be possible. I must be misunderstanding something you are saying."

No it will not go slack because you are powering against it. Once you have forward power, the boat will want to keep moving forward, but the line will not let it, thus holding you tight to the dock. So long as you are in gear, you will have pull against the line.
 
Ok, I think I see my misunderstanding. You guys are not hooking the midship cleat until you are halfway in the slip, you pick up the eye and loop it not from the bow but from the side deck. I was thinking I would be well off the dock and just have the bow in past the dock so someone can pick up the eye from the bow and walk it back to the midship cleat. I can now see that once you cleat the eye at the point you are describing it does indeed "pull" you into the dock.

Thanks guys,
Shel
 
depending on conditions and on the boat, you may need to put some rudders, away from the dock.

if you look at the diagram above, visualize what happens when the prop wash (only one in this case, but it will work with 2 rudders even bettter...) hits the rudder: it pushes the stern sideways.

you cna put the line on the cleat earlier if you want, it won't make any difference until you pick up the slack and power against it.
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

i'm not sure i understand what you mean...

you want to have the spring line coming from teh outer end of the finger pier towards the bow of your boat. as you come bow in, and grab the line, it will slack. as you pull on it, it will get you alongside.

springline.gif







One very important thing to point out that can easily be overlooked with the spring line method as outlined above. Look closely at the rudder. Notice how it is set to drive the stern towards the dock. (Dual inboards would have the port engine in forward.)

Keeping the rudder/outdrives straight or to port could allow the stern to swing out to starboard.
 
Over the years I have had all types of engine set ups. both twin and single. To me the fun is leaving and approaching a dock in all kinds of conditions. The bigger the challenge the more fun it seems to be. It just takes practice and more practice. This topic is very valuable to all. The use of a spring line can be a life saver in any tough conditions.

I do believe that in the next 10yrs or so this whole challenge of docking will go away with the new drive systems that are now available. IPS and Zeus are amazing systems. You can literally make a boat dance around a dock in almost any conditions. I am on my 2nd yr. with my IPS and it is amazing as to what it can do. It will however make people dependent on the system and cause them to be totally incompetent with the normal twin set ups. I am both excited for the new technology that is out and also a little afraid that it will hurt the learning curve for those who at some point may need to rely on the throttles and shifters if and when their system becomes unusable..

I have been out in very difficult situations with the IPS and have not had to use a spring to get me in as of yet. What will happen to the new boater if they ever get into that situation? and they have the IPS. They will not know what to do. I believe that everyone should understand how their boat will handle in unexpected conditons, so practicing, even with the IPS is extremely important to their boating skills. Just my .02 cents.
 
Van: Just as many dont know how to drive a stick shift, dial a telephone or anchor and dock under sail alone, it wont matter
 
quote:

Originally posted by van lafermine

...To me the fun is leaving and approaching a dock in all kinds of conditions. The bigger the challenge the more fun it seems to be. It just takes practice and more practice.






I think this separates boaters who really enjoy it and stay with it for their whole lives, and boaters who may try it for a while and then give it up. If you enjoy the whole docking challenge, and desire to learn, and excel at this particular aspect of boating you are probably a lifer. I see many boaters who are very nervous, with no confidence, and essentially scared to death at docking. They never get over it, they never learn properly, and they either stay at the marina, or they give it up when they have had enough.

For me, there is no feeling like resting that boat up to the dock in a controlled, smooth manner. Very satisfying.

Shel
 
Back
Top