Why i hate a poorly designed ER

PascalG

Moderator
Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2003
RO Number
12212
Messages
12,221
RANT MODE ON

I did an oil and filter change for a friend on a large express.

to get to the oil filters for the port engine, i had to lie on a battery box, slide along the forward bulkhead, rest my head and shoulder on the holding tank, extend my arm under the exhaust hose and stretch out to reach the filter. as expected the filter played hard to get... in the multiple attempt to get it off, i ended up with a bunch of scratches on my arm from the Vee drive cable bracket...

all that because the damn builder was too cheap to relocate the filters where they could be serviced on a boat that retailed for well over 1/2 M when new!!!

ATT02496.jpg


RANT MODE OFF
 
He only had to build the boat, not change the filters. Ever change the plugs on some late model V6s?
 
PG,

I am sure there will be a special place for in the 'boaters heaven'. In the mean time keep the First Aid Kit handy.

Designers are not concerned with turning a wrench, they are more concerned with the creature comforts that mister and misses got rocks look for.

El Sea
 
So did you recommend a filter relocation kit. I'll bet Les and Sib could hook him up!
 
There should be no heaven or hell for engineers and boat builder/designers: They should spend eternity with that which they have created. That should about cover it...
 
"They should spend eternity with that which they have created."

True brother, true.

On that Maxium 46 I brought down from Mich., the only person I could find to reach the stbd engines oil filter was a friends son who is short and very skinny. And he had to pretzel himself up to do it.

I always thought you could make a fortune if you set up a marine mechanics shop staffed by fully trained "little people" to do the work. Child size with adult strength. :-)
 
Could of been worse, could of been frozen on and then you would of really had issues!
 
actually they were Volvo diesels but cant' blame the engines, usually it's the boat builder that relocates the filters as needed depending on the ER layout.
 
"it's the boat builder that relocates the filters ..."

... to the least expensive, easiest to produce, position.

Somewhere along the line the concept of "maintainability" has fallen off the design criteria.
 
Yeah, I was going to say, I wish builders moved oil filters.

On rare occasions they might. But for the most part, from what I've seen over the years, where they come on the engines is where they stay.
 
It's not that the "builder" was being cheap... rather they were trying to build a boat they could sell to the "cheap" buyers... you know... the guys who want the top of the line boat for a low-end price.
Why does 1/2 of America shop at Wal-mart and buy Chinese goods while they watch all the jobs disappear to China and wonder why.. same concept.
 
ps---pascal--- if you want a decent boat, buy a Hat.
Ooops.. you already did...LOL.
 
Man, I am so bummed, I guess it is only quality boat builders that make the filters hard to change.
Now I know I have a cheap boat in my Bayliner,,,, Fuel filters centre and oil filters mounted on the inboard sides of the engines. Port is visible and starboard is behind the blue hoses.

HPIM0801-2.jpg
 
It's a problem not just in boats, but modern cars and trucks too, they might as well have a sign on the engine like TVs used to...."NO USER SERVICABLE PARTS INSIDE"
That's why I have hung onto my ancient Jeep Grand Cherokee with the even more ancient AMC designed 4.0 inline 6, you could teach a 12 year old how to change the oil and tune up that old cast iron monster. Yeah they are a low tech engine that is like a tractor engine compared to the ultra modern V-6s in the Japanese trucks, but it sure is nice to work on.

As far as the boat, accessibilty is one reason why I like my old FW 200 as compared to the newer ones. My old one has the full sun pad and the bench seat across the back, but there is no molded in fiberglass around the rear of the engine compartment like the new ones have. So there is much more room around the stuff that can be a pain to service otherwise like the oil filter, starter, manifolds, etc. I can move the bench seat forward, remove the wood panels on each side of the engine and I put down a cushion (part of the old rear seat I saved) to lie on when I change the oil filter. I know the newer ones have the remote filters which is an improvement, but if they didn't they'd be almost impossible to change without a cap wrench.
 
Anyway to relocate for next time ? I hope you got paid well for the scratches
 
My slender build always served well swinging wrenches (okay, plugging in DDT's) on those 'black' powerplants. Although that was about a decade ago, I still believe they had the right product line for their target market.

Anyways, back on point...

Pascal, see why I found a gig where they not only give me a boat(s) to run but an Engineer to deal with things like that? It's the good life, my friend.

Hey, by the way, I noticed tonight I missed a call from a Florida number earlier today - lost my phonebook with the last cellphone I drowned, but the number still looked real familiar. Was that you? If so, I'll get back to you tomorrow. On duty, but should have an hour or so at some point in the day. (Had both the boys and the dog in the car trying to find a parking spot, so I just didn't have it in me to answer the phone at the moment.
 
Back
Top