Why the cost??

quote:

Originally posted by Billylll

quote:

Originally posted by walterv

Boat builders can charge what they do because they have a captive audience that is willing to pay that price, just that simple. Take away that audience, and the cards fall (todays times).




Walter I believe the house building market is in just as bad shape as boat builders perhaps worse off?
Bill








No, a boat is luxury, a house is a place to live
 
Design, engineering, research and development..

House / Boat - the two should NOT equate. Apple and orange, price per sq / cubic foot doesnt work that way...
4,000 sq ft house on the Deleware river in Trenton NJ $250,000 / 4,000 sq ft house on the beach in Seagirt NJ $12,500,000
 
land is only worth what someone is willing to pay for it... it's strictly offer and demand. good location, high demand high prices... distant suburbs, plenty to lots available, dirt cheap.

i don't know how desirable land is where the original poster lives... here in Miami, they keep pushing new developments out west, 200 or 250 blocks from downtown, the price of land has little impact on the homes and you find some cheap ones.

indeed, apple and oranges. but as i said, you can't even compare the cost of the materials
 
Even in today's market I'm not going to find a place on the water for less than $2M anywhere near the SF Bay Area. At the same time the boat is by no means any type of financial investment. It is however the best quality of life investment I have made in a quite a while. The fact I can go out by myself and enjoy a cruise on the bay, spend a week with just me an the family or take 25 friends out for a day on the bay is worth every penny that goes into the boat. We were originally looking at getting some vacation property or buying a boat. The vacation property had to be on the water and close enough we would use it. Those requirements made the boat a bargain. I love driving the boat and have not yet figured out how to drive my house.
 
Waterfront property in the Bay Area is very expensive, as you have discovered. You can get a break by looking upriver into the Calfornia Delta, but waterfront property there still sells at a premium.

Dockage in the Delta is still a bargain, so is living at anchor if you are willing to relocate every two weeks.

Boats and houses are apples and oranges. One can move and the other doesn't. One can be self-contained and the other needs to be hooked up to utilities. One can be junk in twenty years and the other will appreciate in value.
 
Hmm, water proof switches, corrosion resistant, uh, everything, The ability to hit a dock at 5kts and damage the dock, not the boat. Try running a loaded cement truck ( roughly the weight of a boat ) into your house at 5 kts...

My house does not have radar, nor a plotting GPS, multiple submersible HH radios, A dinette that is designed to be slept upon, multiple power sources ( main fuel , propane stove, 120v and 12 v electrical systems, that actually work together )

For what they are, and what they do, where they do it, boats are cheap.
 
anybody can build a house. watch this old house , rent some tools go to home depot and start assembly. try that with a boat .
 
I put my self thru college building Glasspar boats in Costa Mesa, Ca so I know a little about boat construction. This has been fun but what I guess my bottom line is that the asthetics of owning, operating and being aboard a nice boat is worth the cost of what you pay for it. All the joys of being on the water come at a cost for those of us willing to pay for it. But I still say, aside from all that, the cost of a home versus the cost of a nice boat is, nail vs fiberglass and all that comes with it, is still out of balance.

DBH
 
your boat has 'marine' written on it somewhere, of course it's going to be expensive.
 
It has nothing to do with the hobby or elite nature of being a boat. Boats must cost more to build per sq ft. Just look at the boat makers and note that none of them were ever super profitable. That demonstrates that either all of them are incompetent businesses or their product cost more to build than houses.
 
"Up until the last 6-8 months, houses appreciated year after year and were one the the great investments any homeowner, regardless of the size of their home, could participate in..."

That's ONLY because of the laws of supply and demand, homes are no different than anything else. As long as the demand was up the prices went up, though often not enough to cover taxes and expenses. Then the builders went nuts and increased the supply... and the rest is history.
 
The current market tells me that boats were terribly overpriced. This catastrophe is great if you are a buyer. It sucks if you are a seller.

Boat manufacturers in general should take a very close look at price pointing their product accordingly. Like it or not, Bayliner hit the ball out of the park on this one several decades ago.
 
I bet one normally spends less to maintain a house then to maintain a boat large enough to live on. That is what swayed me away from living aboard when I retired. Too many of my limited retirement dollars would float away and no appreciation to counter that!
 
I am not sure living in a boat is more expensive. You have no real estate taxes that would save me $15k a year alone Liz. Again with a boat you get to move it and it seems to me the more you use them they have fewer problems. On my boat I can make fresh water, I can treat waste, I can also heat water, I can generate enough 12 volts w/ solar to manage the house bank if I watch how many toys are on. You can also make your own electric by running the gen-set if needed. The most expensive part of living on a boat would be moving it long distances. But that was my bad choice when I re-powered. I can easily see living on a boat. My house always has something going wrong with it and I hate paying the real estate taxes and large electric and natural gas bills.
Comparing the costs is almost impossible many houses are cookie cutter most boats have numerous complex upgrades that require they meet all sorts of standards. As another posted the materials used in medium to large size boats is expensive compared to housing materials, heck boats even require special marine grade wire, not simple romex used in many houses.
Bill
 
Every one has different situations. My home taxes, maintenance and repairs, not including upgrades, is way less then dockage and maintenance for a 50 ft vessel. This is without including fuel, just staying at the dock.

But if I ever win the Lotto, I'll go live aboard a nice big boat!!!!
 
I agree.....I think Bayliner hit a home run about twenty years or swo again when they began mass producing and marketing their boats. I don't want to start an argument but I love my 24ft Trophy. Its 12 years old and has never even hiccupped. The hull, layouts and running gear are all first rate....after that things tend to go downhill a bit. The trim, electronics, cleats and all are all cheap and made to hold the cost down. Having said that, I would buy another one tomorrow. What I always say is if I was making my living on my boat, tranversing the ocean or living on it, maybe Bayliner would not be my first choice. But I love mine and it has given me many years of great servsice.....looks pretty nice when we are chasing salmon on Monterey Bay too.

DBH
 
DBH, why did you ask the question when you already had your mind made up?

You want to make a real comparison, then I submit to you the cost of let's say a one carat, diamond engagement ring. The initial price of purchase for size-of-thing acquired is one thing. The ongoing maintenance makes boating pale in comparison. Like a boat, all in exchange for a few priceless moments...

George
 
I for one would rather pay more and have top quality fittings that I dont have to continuously worry about. Nothing worse than cheap boat bits that break when the kids touch them, or come loose /discolour / rust after just a few hours of normal useage.

Quality inclusions, which most newly build boats have,(due to customer demand) will cost much much more, but will last and look new forever.

There are plenty of cheap boats with cheap fit-outs if that is what a buyer wants. Just be prepared to have no luxury, lots of annoying repairs to be done and the basic boat can be had cheaply.

Most boat-owners I know like the fact that sometimes their boats are more luxurious (albiet smaller) than their homes. I'm sure most of you will agree.
 
Well i have read all the responses and here's my take. You are comparing your house to a boat..ok, Where do you think that boat was built....ON LAND. Ever see the size of a factory that builds these boats. ( probably millions of dollars ) It's huge. Now take that in to account what that building ( might as well be a large house ) that has to be built to build that boat. Now heat that building, pay all the people, liability insurance, and the list goes on and on. Just my opinion.
 
Back
Top