Yanmar repower

Greg Schoenberg

Member
exMember
Joined
Feb 19, 2006
RO Number
20280
Messages
444
I'm considering two Sam Devlin 27' trailerable trawlers. One is fully restore with tons of amenities. However, it's powered by a Yanmar 44 hp. Top speed 11 knots/cruise is 7.

Other is more basic, 20k less, and powered by a Yanmar 66 hp. Top speed is 14 knots/cruise is 10.

I prefer a bigger engine. If I were to get the deluxe boat with the 44 hp, what would be the ball park cost of upgrading to a 66 hp or higher. Can it be done with rebuilding the existing engine or is a replacement necessary?

TIA

-Greg
 
Buy em' both. Swap engines and sell the one you dont want!

Greg, I worked for a company in Seattle that did those kinds of swaps. Back in the days of Wooden boats though.
(With a Wood boat you can do almost anything and not have a problem)

We had a Marine Engineer. A guy who really knew his stuff when it came to engine changes. I'm not advising against a swap, just to contact a Marine engineer over what your thinking of doing this time.
Since we were directed by this Marine Engineer, nothing ever went wrong on our jobs so I dont know all the pitfalls you might encounter.

Wouldnt the '44/great boat' be OK? About 2.5 Gal/hr at cruise? I seem to recall that Small Diesels run about 5Gph/100Hp.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Thudpucker

Buy em' both. Swap engines and sell the one you dont want!

Greg, I worked for a company in Seattle that did those kinds of swaps. Back in the days of Wooden boats though.
(With a Wood boat you can do almost anything and not have a problem)

We had a Marine Engineer. A guy who really knew his stuff when it came to engine changes. I'm not advising against a swap, just to contact a Marine engineer over what your thinking of doing this time.
Since we were directed by this Marine Engineer, nothing ever went wrong on our jobs so I dont know all the pitfalls you might encounter.

Wouldnt the '44/great boat' be OK? About 2.5 Gal/hr at cruise? I seem to recall that Small Diesels run about 5Gph/100Hp.






Intriguing idea about buying them both but I would think it would be easier to sell the existing engine and replacing it.

The seller is claiming .6 ghp at 6 knot cruise. That's 10 mpg.

This would be my first trawler. I'm just wondering if I can truly go that slow and enjoy it.

You sound familiar with wooden boats. Question...the kind that Devlin makes, with the expoxy and so forth, they are much easier to paint compared to fiberglass hulls...correct?

-Greg
 
I dont know the name Devlin.
The Best, the very bestus wooden boat I ever had was a Tolly craft. They used some kind of pressed wood with a special glue. I think they called it MDO. It was just great. Took paint well and was so smooth you could actually sand or scrape the paint off without damaging the wood.
Old and creaky as I am, if I ever considered another wooden boat the only one I'd ever consider would be a Tolly craft. You gotta be young and agile to own a wooden boat.
You've seen photos of yzer's boat! He must be a pretty versitle guy to own a boat like that.

Wood and epoxy mix pretty well.
However every board has six sides. If you dont get the Epoxy in all six sides, and into the wood at least .030 (Heat pressed) and do that when the wood is good and dry, you're gonna get a lot of moisture inside the wood, underneath the Epoxy coating.
If you make any Mod's at all on one of those Epoxy laden Arc's you expose the wood to the atmosphere and suddenly you gotta cover it or it begins to deteriorate right while your working on it. Without a lot of experience, (if you dont have me sitting in a comfortable chair directing your work) its just gonna create more work for your future.

I'm a little skittish about your plan to sell that engine. There's a lot to buying a used engine to replace an existing power-plant. So much stuff to move or buy new.

I took two perfectly good Izuzu 4-Cyl Diesel's out of my ChrisCraft and couldnt sell em'.
Had the Reversing gear, shaft's, props, engine guages and wiring, etc. All of it was complete. I advertised in a lot of pub's for almost a year and finally wound up selling both to a Junkie for a couple hundred bucks.

On that 6 Kt cruise. I dunnoo??? Assume 100 miles to Neah Bay. 16 hours underway. Three days if you decided to go to Westport. A trip down to Hood Canal for some Oyster digging would be a two day trip.
Time to a guy like you is way more important than some other folks. You'll wind up having somebody else drive the boat up there, and you'll charter a float plane ride to your boat.

When I had my 22' Cedar boat in Shilshoe bay, I'd go up to Sequi, Neah bay etc for a long weekend. I spent most of the time in transit because of the 10 Mph cruise. (can you imagine doing that now with no instruments other than a binacle compass and a wrist watch?)
It was all that wasted time that finally drove me to the faster more applicable Trailer boats.
(Aside on that long slow trip. I used to put a Salmon rod in a Pole holder, with a big Salmon fly on the line and no weight. I'd set the fly so it was streaming up, over, and back on the wake of the boat. I caught three Silvers doing that)

I envy you your choices. IMO I'd buy the boat without the emenities, the bigger motor, and add what you want later on.

You will absolutly love that .6 Gph cruise though. There's no better feeling of security on a long voyage than to see that fuel guage way up into the green.
 
"Question...the kind that Devlin makes, with the expoxy and so forth, they are much easier to paint compared to fiberglass hulls...correct?"

No
 
devlon also sells kits for the diy'er. are you looking into purchasing a boat that the company put together, or one a backyard builder did. there are some awesome guys who build boats from kits. however, i would think at re-sale time it might hurt you.
 
Back
Top