Bad fuel Question

Wow, I really appreciate all of the great advice!

So I have heard 2 pieces of advice one was its bad to mix new good fuel with the old fuel, and the other was its ok to mix the good and bad fuel. Can I get more opinions on this matter?

Also, I will change all 3 filters now, but do I need to keep changing all 3 filters often or just the screw on filter located on the wall of the boat?
 
Zach,

Let me add to my previous answer. I stated that until you can confirm what you problem is (or isn't) I wouldn't go adding new gas to the old. The better answer is it depends. I am a pretty firm believer in diagnosing the problem, not guessing, before taking a fix.

If either the the old gas contained ethanol or the new gas will contain ethanol I believe you should do the work to figure out what the current problem is and determine if there is any phase separated water layer at the bottom of the tank. Adding more gas to such a mix can make matters worse, or create new problems.

If the new gas will contain ethanol and the old gas is not phase separated you still want to get as much of the old gas out of the tank(s) as possible before you add new. Mixing new E-gas with old has created many problems, like some of those mentioned here. Better to avoid them.

The one situation where I would add new gas is if I could confirm that there is no phase separated water layer in the tank now and the new gas would be traditional, ethanol-free MTBE gas. In that case I would go for the highest octane I could find, as gas looses octane over prolonged storage, and I would add as much new gas as I could fit in the tank.

Changing filters now is a good start. Try that along with some of the other suggestions about checking venting and the anti siphon valve(s). These are fairly easy to do and may resolve your problem. If it does, then use up as much of the old as you can and then add new. I do like the idea of dumping the filters into a container to get a look at what you may be dealing with.

Good luck !
 
DSM, I think that Eric has summed it up nicely, Try some of the easy things first while checking the gas. Filters, ani-Siphon valves, checking venting etc. will keep it under $100 and are all good thinsg to have done. Remember that your baot sat for a period of time so you may have multiple small issues, these steps will start to clear them up. The hard part is that you shoudl do one thing, take a test run and see how it worked then try the next thing. This will also provide you some of the practice you were referring to. Now, if your boat is not with you due to the aborted trip, yuo may have to expidite the process adn try several small things first. (i.e. filters and ant-siphon) there is no harm here but you may not know which is the casue and filters can cog again.

If you indeed have a single fuel tank, I suspect that your fuel is not the only cause . However, Eric is right, use as much of it as you can and then refill with fresh. Also add a stabilizer fo fuel treatment at each fill up to avoid fuel issues in the future.

AS you add Ethanol gas (you may have it in the tank already since you are in he midwest) you may end up with "gunk" from the fuel tanks going through the filters as ethannol is a solvent and will clean up the fuel tanks. Always keep extra fuel filters on board as well as the equipment to chaneg them (i,e, coffee can or equivalent to catch gas. I would also invest in the Racor filters at some point so you can drain the water without changing the filter.
 
I keep hearing about these racor filters. How do they work? How do they drain out the water?
 
They basically are a filter with a plastci cap attached at the bottom, Teh water collects in the cap nd the cap has a drain valve to let the water out. Vasically RACOR makes a better filter than most and with the water sitting in the bottom of the cap, it is not saturating the filter or the fuel. Plus you can tell when you are getting a little water or a lot.

Here are some examples http://www.boatfix.com/catalog/511.pdf
 
btw, please let us know if you find the problem, it's good for the following readers.
 
Scott, those Racors with the clear plastic bowls are not approved for inboard use. The ones for inboards have a metal bowl.
 
Greg,

Thansk for correcting me. I have I/O's and don't have a Racor myself (the baot caem with the spin on mounst and I wasn't abel to find the right racor filetr)
 
quote:

Originally posted by Britanic

I have a 88 34 silverton with 350/270 crusaders - you probably have 454.
First question - do you have a manual fuel pump?
Second question - did you add anything to the fuel?

Dont rule out the engines ignition system yet!






Zach,

Here is what I would do;
Empty the contents of the first (from tank) filter into a clear container, even a zip lock bag will work. If there is any water it will show quickly. I doubt you will see any and dont think your problem is bad fuel. I have found that "bad fuel" is rarley the culprit.

I am pretty sure you have one tank and as someone else said, if the other engine is running OK from the same tank, can't be the fuel.

On the mechanical fuel pump. Remove the flame arrestor from the carb and try to find a vacuum line conected to the carburator. It will be a flexible rubber hose. This will lead to the fuel pump. Remove the hose and make sure it is clean. Then make sure the fitting in the carb is clean and clear, to be prositive blow into the fitting, it should pass air easily. Then make sure the fitting on the fuel pump is clear, you can inset a small philip head screw driver in the fitting.

If you are having trouble finding the fuel pump follow the fuel line from the tank. The pump will be mounted to the engine and will have metal lines running to the carb. If your pump has wiries running to it, it is electrical and you will not find the vacuum line.

IF you have a mechanical fuel pump, this vacuum line could very well be the problem. If your fuel looks clean and the vacuum line is clear, check the anti siphon valve.

My opinion on fuel additives (with the exception of stabilizer for winter storage) is not to use them and run the boat often instead. This is also the opinion of several marine mechanics I know.

Good luck, and keep us posted.
 
To keep you all updated. I actually had the Brokerage I bought the boat from work on the boat. I gave them a printout of this thread for reference. They said they started with replacing all of the fuel filters (all 6 of them, 3 on each engine) and took the boat out for a bit for a sea trial. It passed the sea trial and ran fine. So I am going to bring the boat home the 100 mile trip and do all of the things this thread says. I will also give it a full tune up. Hopefully the boat runs fine on the way home. I am going to bring a few extra spin on filters with me just in case. Ill keep the forum posted on how well this works. Thanks for ALL of the help!!!!

Zach
 
Could be E 10 gas cleaning all the gunk out of your fuel system and clogging up the filters. Take extras with you for your trip.
 
Ok, so I went down and got the boat after the machanic changed all 3 fuel filters on the engine. The boat ran great at 3000 rpms (20 mph) for about 2 hours. Then all of the sudden the boats starboard engine did the exact same thing it was doing before. Going from 3000 rpms, doen to 200 or so, then back up and so on. So I pulled the boat down to 1500 rpms and brought it into the closets harbor. I bought a new fuel filter and put it on. Now the starboard engine wont even start. The fuel that was in the filter was absolutly horrible. There was so much debris and slimy stuff in there that I could not even believe it. And the fuel filters were only run for about 2 hours. Im so puzzled though. Why is only the starboard engine acting up and not the port? There is only one fuel tank...I am having the marina take a look at the boat...any futher suggestions?? This is turning out to be a very unpleasant introduction to the world of boating for me.
 
I am gonna guess that each engine has it's own fuel pickup, and that the starboard pickup is closer to the bottom of the tank, thereby picking up more "stuff" (for lack of a better name).

You need to get a hose to the very bottom of the tank and pump all that "stuff" out. And carry several spare fuel filters for what you can't pump out.
 
And I am going to guess that Willie is right. I am also going to guess that if you saw slime, that boat had E-10 gas in it and has phase separated. You probably don't have enough bad stuff in it to overwhelm the pickup, bus as you run it mixes, gets dispersed and gets picked up. It's time to get a sample from the bottom of the tank. If you do have a phase separated layer you do not want to run it through the engines.
 
Yup, sounds like E 10 phase separation. It's going to be an ugly summer until the system is cleaned out.
 
Did you check the rotors and points? Is the distributor cap cracked/wet?

Have you had it tuned up?
 
Whe're you at on your trip?

Sounds like it would be a good idea to pump the tank a get some new gas. Welcome to boating. Good luck.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Golfman25

Whe're you at on your trip?

Sounds like it would be a good idea to pump the tank a get some new gas. Welcome to boating. Good luck.






I am currently in Waukegan harbor at Larson Marine. I will print this forum again to give the machanics your suggestions. A full tume up has not been given yet, but we will do that. So the slime is ethonal gas seperation?
 
Like I said I am guessing. The brown bits of gunk are probably old gasoline gums and varnish. Normally these will accumulate in a tank and in lines for years and never create a problem. Add some E-gas and they tend to get dissolved and dislodged form the surface. They typically look like and are often mistaken for rust particles. The very fine ones can really clog things up. Now, if you add enough water to that mix of varnish, gums and E-gas to get phase separation, it can become slimy or gel-like. The varnish and gums get partially dissolved and act as thickeners in the water-dominant phase.

My guess is that it could also happen within a water separating filter even if you don't have enough water in the tank to separate - low levels of water separate in the filter and creates the same effect there.

I would want to find out what is in the tank, how much crud may be in the fuel in the tank and if there is any water layer in the tank. Another thing you want to find out is if the gasoline in the area where the boat is from generally contained ethanol.
 
Back
Top