Here we go again...

quote:

Originally posted by HOGAN

Your comments could result in someone losing their life.








And that Hogan is the scariest part of this conversation. He truly does not see the danger in his comments. Very sad indeed.
 
Here I am again, let's see if Les will agree with this. Don't go there in a 16 ft. boat, would not be smart. Anyone that went there, should not, the law says have PFD's, but with no radio, I don't think it matters.
 
quote:

Originally posted by blouderback

Sorry if I've been taken the wrong way here. My point is that the operator of this boat made several mistakes, but the fact that he went into the ocean in a 16' boat was not one of them, as baull stated at the end of the original post.

Mistake #1: no VHF radio on board.
Mistake #2: no signalling device(s) on board.
Mistake #3: going out too far without a backup plan.
Mistake #4: leaving the boat after it capsized.






If you think those are the only 4 contributing factors to the accident at hand, you are not even worth replying to any more.

BTW - how do you know he left the boat, and was not thrown from it and could not get back to it?

You ever try climbing back on the hull of a boat that has capsized Bob?
 
I'd put it more on stupidity than the size of the boat. Folks have CROSSED THE ATLANTIC in boats a lot smaller than 16', and lived to talk about it.
 
"we would have gotten the boat back into safe waters when it became disabled, or it wouldn't have become disabled because we would have done the proper maintenance and/or pre trip checks."

that has to be one of the most ignorant things i've seen here... why dont' explain to us how you get a boat back thru an inlet, on your own, after it becomes disabled !

I'd love to hear it... do you row ? do you get in the water and swim pulling the boat with a bow line in your teeth ? or do you push it at the stern ?

please tell us, I'm sure many members would love to save on Sea Tow or Boat Us fees...

if you think a VHF and flares is going to do much good on a 16' that's disabled, taking on water over the stern and rolling over, good luck! it takes VERY little to flood and capsize a small boat (under 25'), seconds... you won't have time to call the CG and give them the needed info before the batteries and VHF are under water. and good luck finding your flare box and emergency equipement in a capsized boat...

if you think you can overcome all of the above, good luck... you're kidding yourself !
 
And some have survived going over Niagara Falls in a barrel Willie doesn't make it a smart thing to do.
 
quote:

Originally posted by In the know

quote:

Originally posted by blouderback

Sorry if I've been taken the wrong way here. My point is that the operator of this boat made several mistakes, but the fact that he went into the ocean in a 16' boat was not one of them, as baull stated at the end of the original post.

Mistake #1: no VHF radio on board.
Mistake #2: no signalling device(s) on board.
Mistake #3: going out too far without a backup plan.
Mistake #4: leaving the boat after it capsized.






If you think those are the only 4 contributing factors to the accident at hand, you are not even worth replying to any more.

BTW - how do you know he left the boat, and was not thrown from it and could not get back to it?

You ever try climbing back on the hull of a boat that has capsized Bob?








That would be an interesting poll...will Bob be likely to have to attempt to crawl back on the hull of his capsized boat....

J/K Bob...but I could Photoshop you a pic of that....
 
"we would have..."

I hope that's you and that mouse in your pocket, because this "we" would not go out in conditions that this "we" was not confident of surviving in. Sounds like most of the "we's" here agree with that sentiment as well. I think, Bob, that you too often try to be flippant and I seriously hope you do not really believe what you say. But if you do, that is ok too.
 
"The fact that you (and others) can't understand that a 16' boat is NOT inherently dangerous in and of itself is rather annoying.

The boat was not ill-equipped, as you say, the operator was."

So tell us again why you haven"t yet made the trip to Block Island? After all..............if the Boat size isn"t an issue.......then why haven"t you been there yet?
 
Bob, Bob!
Why are you approaching that hornets nest with a stick in your hand?
 
I have been boating for 50 years. The two most "COMMON" problems are common courtesy and in this case common sense.
 
Based on the first post - IMO, I think they were very fortunate to have lost only one life. The survivor was very lucky indeed, it's tragic that he lost his brother in this incident. A huge price to pay for poor judgment.

Would I have taken a 16’ boat out in those conditions? No way.. and probably not a boat twice that size. I agree that better safety equipment would have been a good idea, but I wouldn't have put myself and/or family in such a situation to begin with.. it's a matter of common sense and knowing your limitations.
 
quote:

Originally posted by stmbtwle

Quite a few who did make it decided to SHIP the boat back home, too. Maybe they'd had enough?






I'd like to think it's because most humans learn from their mistakes!
 
Yes, you are ALL right. I see my errors. ALL small boats are dangerous and should be banned.
 
quote:

Originally posted by blouderback

Yes, you are ALL right. I see my errors. ALL small boats are dangerous and should be banned.




Especially bow riders and pontoon boats..
 
quote:

Originally posted by blouderback

Yes, you are ALL right. I see my errors. ALL small boats are dangerous and should be banned.






Don't be a putz Bob. That's not the intent here and you know it. Different boats are designed for different types of boating. There is nothing wrong with using a boat in the manner in which it was designed for.

Using a lake boat in open waters can be extremely risky even under good conditions. You have yet to learn to respect the power of the sea. I sure hope you don't learn the hard way.
 
quote:

Originally posted by stmbtwle

Quite a few who did make it decided to SHIP the boat back home, too. Maybe they'd had enough?

I liked the one about the guy who crossed the Atlantic with a 2-1/2hp outboard. http://www.tohatsu.com/news/seiko.html






I wonder how he dealt with the fuel issue. Could he have carried enough fuel to make the journey or did he get supplies dropped to him on the way?
 
Back
Top