Here we go again...

Yup. put it this way: Let's say the definition of "small craft" is, for sake of argument, 20 feet. Now, a "small craft" advisory is issued. Would anyone of us go out in my 20' 6" boat, which would not be considered a "small craft" as I defined it? Of course not. I think that's why the Coast Guard intentionally does NOT define what a small craft is.

By the way, this argument can be made with 10', 30', 40', etc.
 
Bob, just in case this plays out on Joe's boat, and I happen to be there, I like my martini's nice and cold and shaken to the point of having those little ice crystals. We'll let Joe take care of the rest.
 
Bob, all this because you took offense to baull’s one sentence comment at the end of the original story in the very first post of this thread “(or maybe DON'T GO INTO THE OCEAN IN A 16' BOAT)”???? What part of “maybe” is unclear to you? Some day’s it “maybe” unsafe to venture into the ocean in such a boat of this size and some days it maybe fine, all things being considered prior to launch. Apparently most here understand this very basic concept. You seem to have an obsession about size and any reference to "small". Could size be something more personal to you than just boating?

FWIW they were in a bass boat.
 
WOW! Up 'till now I've thought this thread was a little hard on Bob. That is a really low blow Estimator! Very personal indeed
 
LOL Michael, We are all allowed our opinions, unless Les decides otherwise. You can read into my post anything you want. I see from your profile that you are a woman...a quick one I might add.
 
Well, I thought I'd get some responses to this post -- but not THIS many!
Sorry if I offended any of you seasoned mariners, but I still think going 4 miles out in the Atlantic in a 16' boat IS NOT A GOOD IDEA. And if you think a 60' would not be any safer, under the same conditions...
/Bill
 
Bob the boat size was one component to this deadly event, not the sole reason. Regards Bill
 
quote:

Originally posted by Estimator

FWIW they were in a bass boat.





I see these out on Lake Erie in 3-4' chop all the time... I've always questioned if they are really very safe in that wave height? Personally, I feel they are OK on a smaller inland lake, river, bay etc.. Open water - only in conditions that will allow.
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

"we would have gotten the boat back into safe waters when it became disabled, or it wouldn't have become disabled because we would have done the proper maintenance and/or pre trip checks."

that has to be one of the most ignorant things i've seen here... why dont' explain to us how you get a boat back thru an inlet, on your own, after it becomes disabled !

I'd love to hear it... do you row ? do you get in the water and swim pulling the boat with a bow line in your teeth ? or do you push it at the stern ?

please tell us, I'm sure many members would love to save on Sea Tow or Boat Us fees...

if you think a VHF and flares is going to do much good on a 16' that's disabled, taking on water over the stern and rolling over, good luck! it takes VERY little to flood and capsize a small boat (under 25'), seconds... you won't have time to call the CG and give them the needed info before the batteries and VHF are under water. and good luck finding your flare box and emergency equipement in a capsized boat...

if you think you can overcome all of the above, good luck... you're kidding yourself !






I've seen small boats capsize and 25 seconds is generous. It's more like 10.

Bob, you need to stop giving advice or doling out your ignorant opinions. You're dangerous on your own, let alone on the water.
 
Hey genius, please point out the "advice" I gave out on this forum that was dangerous.
 
quote:

Originally posted by blouderback

Hey genius, please point out the "advice" I gave out on this forum that was dangerous.






All of it
 
You mean like:
quote:


Mistake #1: no VHF radio on board.
Mistake #2: no signalling device(s) on board.
Mistake #3: going out too far without a backup plan.
Mistake #4: leaving the boat after it capsized.





or
quote:


The boat was not ill-equipped, as you say, the operator was.





or
quote:


Having proper signalling equipment on board might have saved the fellow's life.





or
quote:


the operator made several deadly errors in taking ANY boat out into the ocean without the proper gear or experience. So, back to MY original reply, the size of the boat does not matter in this case.





or
quote:


small boats are safe, as long as YOU, the operator, take the proper precauations and have the proper training and/or experience.





or
quote:


I am not advocating that 16' boats belong in the ocean in bad conditions operated by inexperienced people without proper safety equipment. However, with the proper preparedness, experience, caution, and weather conditions, a 16' boat can, in fact, go out on the ocean safely.





or
quote:


Boating safely is, as Ghost and other have indicated time and time again, mainly in the hands of the operator, and what he/she knows, and not the equipment.





or
quote:


what good is the equipment if I don't have the proper knowledge to use it?





or
quote:


Now, a "small craft" advisory is issued. Would anyone of us go out in my 20' 6" boat, which would not be considered a "small craft" as I defined it? Of course not.





All quotes from me.
 
How about these beauties Bob:

If the size of the boat matters, then why did the 729 foot Edmund Fitzgerald go down? I guess it was too small to be out on Lake Superior.

All I'm saying is that size doesn't matter. At least that what I've always been told.


YOU, or me, or any of the other folks on this board who like to haze me would not have had that problem on that boat. We would not have gone out, or we would have had the proper hailing/signaling equipment, or we would have gotten the boat back into safe waters when it became disabled, or it wouldn't have become disabled because we would have done the proper maintenance and/or pre trip checks. IT'S NOT THE BOAT'S FAULT!
 
Back
Top