Insurance update...

It looks to me the attorney in that case is criminal defense. You need a admiralty specialist Art.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Capt. Art

I appreciate all the suggestions. It appears that the consensus is to hire an attorney? I still feel it's a little too early but I'm going to look for a lawyer experienced in this area & see what the retainer costs will be?





Getting an attorney/lawyer is not a bad idea if you are getting nowhere. One thing to keep in mind is who they work for. Either they work for a firm or they may be independent. Their objective is to run up a tab. Once they get a foot in the door on a half millon+ claim, the attorney will milk it out.
I would hold off a little longer. See if you can find out what information they need before paying the claim.
As mentioned, the insurance company wants to be sure this is a valid claim. If you check your credit report, you should see that they looked at it.
 
I agree the Ins. co. is just covering their a$$ on this and would like to make sure she went down and if they can find out why.It's hard to wait it out and make payments on it when you know it's gone. But how long would a biz be around if they didn't check out every sinking and fire and in times like this they go up. It just makes since.
 
quote:

Originally posted by GeeBee

It looks to me the attorney in that case is criminal defense. You need a admiralty specialist Art.





I posted that link because earlier someone had asked about a Boat loss and criminal charges being filed in Nassau/Suffolk Countys. However that case is obviously different than what is going on with Art. This couple lost their home and boat coincidence or not? What I didn't like the insurance company refused to pay on the boat because exhaust hoses failed and the bilge pumps were shut off. I have not been in a boat yet that had boat "off" switches for bilges. The boat was the 1st claim the house was later.
Bill
 
Since this is a case about a loss on the water/sea would a proctor in admiralty be appropriate? When hiring a lawyer you want one that knows the ropes for your type of case. As stated, this is not an insurance claim on your house.

P.S. As intersting as this is to follow:

DITTO Per Hogan: Post NOTHING about the sinking on a public forum.
 
quote:

What I didn't like the insurance company refused to pay on the boat because exhaust hoses failed and the bilge pumps were shut off. I have not been in a boat yet that had boat "off" switches for bilges. Bill






Bill - here is the info from the article:

The District Attorney said investigators determined that someone had disconnected one raw-water intake hose from a diesel engine and one diesel-generator exhaust hose, causing the sinking. The salvage crew also found that three bilge-pump switches were turned off.

I think what they found was that 2 hoses were disconnected and the bilge pump switches were off - obviously the boat probably had automatic pumps, with manual override switches. I know my mainship does, and if it was sinking, you would be sure all three would be in the manual override position when they hauled her from the bottom...
 
quote:

Originally posted by ronlord

quote:

What I didn't like the insurance company refused to pay on the boat because exhaust hoses failed and the bilge pumps were shut off. I have not been in a boat yet that had boat "off" switches for bilges. Bill






Bill - here is the info from the article:

The District Attorney said investigators determined that someone had disconnected one raw-water intake hose from a diesel engine and one diesel-generator exhaust hose, causing the sinking. The salvage crew also found that three bilge-pump switches were turned off.

I think what they found was that 2 hoses were disconnected and the bilge pump switches were off - obviously the boat probably had automatic pumps, with manual override switches. I know my mainship does, and if it was sinking, you would be sure all three would be in the manual override position when they hauled her from the bottom...







Ron I have a Mainship as well and the only thing you can do is put the switches in automatic or manually on. To be honest putting the switches in manual would not discharge any additional water than if left in the automatic position. So if the boat was pumping on all 3 why throw the switches?
In addition in a prior thread I mentioned I have a 3700GPH aux pump with a float switch that is about 6" higher than the other pumps with a loud alarm and a manual "on" switch. I won't get into my spare.
There isn't any way the bilge pumps would have anything to do with that sinking other than slowing it down unless the wires were cut to them.
As far as the generator did they say if the through hull was open or closed perhaps they have service records to support their claim about the generator being out of service?
The cause could have been a single failure the exhaust hose wasn't properly clamped or bacame compromissed. I don't know what water pressure would do to hoses on a boat in 200 feet of water perhaps nothing perhaps everything?
I am simply trying to point out no one wants to be "tried in the press". A simple misplaced word can make things look a whole lot different than the actual situation. For me these people fit the "model" for high insurance risk. Were they ever found guilty? I have no idea and many times you won't read about a positive outcome only the negative. I am neither defending them or condemming them.
Bill
 
I have an old 1980 Chris Craft. The switches are ON, OFF, AUTO. I have 2 set up like that from the factory.
I added an auto only pump with an inline fuse, no switch, just to give me a warm and fuzzy feeling.
 
My 3 pumps also have/had an On Position & and an Automatic On activated by a float switch or senser setup. There was no off? To turn my pumps off I think you'd have to disconnect the battery.
 
quote:

Originally posted by rduhon

I have an old 1980 Chris Craft. The switches are ON, OFF, AUTO. I have 2 set up like that from the factory.
I added an auto only pump with an inline fuse, no switch, just to give me a warm and fuzzy feeling.






Ok, so the boat in question was a 1983 - maybe had the same switches as rduhons? If they were found in the OFF position, I would think that would raise some questions.
 
My 87 Carver 3607 has off switches to the 3 main bilge pumps next to the battery switch in my aft cabin stand up locker. They will shut down the pumps. I've taped in the on position it's to easy to hit them and shut them off.
 
quote:

Originally posted by talexander38

My 87 Carver 3607 has off switches to the 3 main bilge pumps next to the battery switch in my aft cabin stand up locker. They will shut down the pumps. I've taped in the on position it's to easy to hit them and shut them off.





I would go one step further and bypass the switches so no matter what they get power just make sure each is properly fused.
Bill
 
My 1985 Carver 3607's battery switch is under the bottom step entering the main salon from outside the boat but there is no switch to the three main bilge pumps.
The shower sump pumps are switched at the main power panel along with all the other power switches and breakers but my main bilge pumps are live at all times as long as I have charged batteries.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Billylll

quote:

Originally posted by talexander38

My 87 Carver 3607 has off switches to the 3 main bilge pumps next to the battery switch in my aft cabin stand up locker. They will shut down the pumps. I've taped in the on position it's to easy to hit them and shut them off.





I would go one step further and bypass the switches so no matter what they get power just make sure each is properly fused.
Bill








And at this point if you are not ABYC (or what ever they call themselves) certified, you have screwed yourself out of a valid claim.
Make sure you have changes made by qualified people and have receipts for the work.
 
Mine are wired that way from Carver. And they meet ABYC for it's date of manufacture. that's why they're taped on. And I've found that no 2 boats are alike yr to yr
 
I am a member of the ABYC there is nothing in the rules about upgrading a vessel to current standards, using the proper gauge and type wire for the device, proper crimp connectors, fused properly that would void your insurance. You don't need to be certified to do work on your boat especially upgrading to a current standard insurance companies require surveys so if you have done a complete wiring project on an insured vessel get one otherwise small upgrades done properly would never void your policy. Especially beefing up the bilge pumps and their circuit. So unless you did something really dumb like using regular wire instead of marine grade wire or the bilge wiring was routed so it was laying in the water at all times disabling a fused off bilge switch would never be a reason for denial unless you wanted to brag to the insurance company how well your bilge downgrade was. If you have an expensive boat that is older than 10 years you may find your insurance company will want current surveys what ever period they decide. Yes Boatbum I agree it is best to have a pro do the work and have the receipts. Also just because your bilge switch says off that may only mean the manual override for the float switch is off, perhaps not. That would be easy to check by putting the switch to off and lifting the float switch. Float switches should be checked almost as often as sniffing for fumes in a bilge or checking your oil.
Bill
 
The boat in question is a late model SeaRay. SeaRays are wired such that there is no auto position. When the switch is down, it is in auto, the float switch commands the pump, that is the default position. When the switch is up, the pump runs regardless of the float signal.
 
Bayliner uses 6 pumps, 3 auto and three separate switched ones.
The only way to disable the auto pumps is to throw the breakers on the main panel in the engine room.
 
art be careful what you post i would sit back this will take a while first a 2001 million dollar boat does not just sink for no explained reason or hull breach. if you get a check within a year i will be very surprized as they are searching for a way not to pay a big claim if they do find a defect it will go all the way back to the builder to see if there is a problem with other boats. theres a lot more but i won,t post it here!
 
having off switches on the bilge pumps is nice to prevent accidental discharge in case of a leak or something, for instance during a filter change. things happen... being able to turn off the pumps while you mop up saves you from leaving a slick in the water.

BUT, they should have a safety cover on to make sure they're not accidentally turned off.

underwriters require surveys to make sure boats are up to standards, i really doubt a claim could be denied unless you can prove something was installed by a "pro".... this is ridiculous! define "pro" anyway... half of the "mechanics" out there know little about electrical system anyway and if you've been around boats long enough you have seen things done by "pros" that makes you shake your head in disbelief.
 
Back
Top