Insurance update...

Art should have had an insurance survey if it was insured. That in itself tells the insurance company
that the boat is within that insurance companies standards in order to even get insurance.
I don't think they will go as far as a wiring problem if the boat sank as fast as it did. It had to
have been some kind of catastrophic failure to sink a 53 ft. boat so fast that it was almost impossible
to deploy the dingy.
 
Hey what P said.. Pros had a pro work on the carb for my gen set before I took over the boat in Feb. 3 months later the gen set failed, no fuel to it. We were on a 4 day trip so I started looking in to it pulled the carb a part and found a black piece of hard rubber in the needle. Guess what the pro didn't use USCG gas hose. the 10% corn gas ate it. So much for pro's. I've gone over my systems and can track down all my hoses and all the major wire runs and have the valves name tagged ( Navy thing ) and most of all learn from this an one other sight what makes sense and what doesn't. We all need to remember the ABYC changes things all the time yr to yr. And BillyIII you're now on my what about this list..and I always have one of those ;)
 
Mine have no "off" position either. If I REALLY need to shut one down I can still pull the fuse.
 
quote:

Originally posted by boatbum

quote:

Originally posted by Billylll

quote:

Originally posted by talexander38

My 87 Carver 3607 has off switches to the 3 main bilge pumps next to the battery switch in my aft cabin stand up locker. They will shut down the pumps. I've taped in the on position it's to easy to hit them and shut them off.





I would go one step further and bypass the switches so no matter what they get power just make sure each is properly fused.
Bill








And at this point if you are not ABYC (or what ever they call themselves) certified, you have screwed yourself out of a valid claim.
Make sure you have changes made by qualified people and have receipts for the work.










I've read about 5 different policy's front to back to understand what is REALLY in them, instead of just trusting the large amount of inaccurate rumor that is fed around the forums.

While these things are not always that easy to read, must be taken in total, and the first one is definately the hardest to read. Well, I've never ready anything that ever mentioned maintenance work being done by ABYC certified personnel. In fact, I don't recall reading much of anything that references the quality of work performed.

Maybe you know something I don't, but it would be useful to have some backup of the above comments to determine their accuracy. I suspect this might just be more rumor based facts than anything.

Ultimately I suspect that the survey process is the mechanism by which insurance companies address issues with workmanship.
 
quote:

Originally posted by tugboat kevin

if you get a check within a year i






A year? I'll loose my slip if I don't have a boat in it by Spring? The marina won't hold my spot longer then that? What's the point of paying for insurance if it's not there when you need it?
 
Arty,

We can put my boat there!

I started a thread a year or two ago where we turned over a half million dollar plus crane and damaged a structure being built. Simple cause is my book, and as stated in that thread.

I know it is not the same, but our insurance is still in litigation with the many parties that “could” be involved in any way with the upset as to spread the liability around beyond the obvious, even as far as to the mechanics that worked on it under warranty. It was only a few months old.

Great adviceinfo has been given here…please call and keep me updated. I’m glad they are going to look at her. It might be an inherent problem that others might not be as lucky as you and your son to survive. Many may benefit from your misfortune.

Look how much good came from the original thread, and I know that was hard for you to write and answer. You took great care of Lady M, it will be good to know what killed her.

Your friend…Stan
 
quote:

What's the point of paying for insurance if it's not there when you need it?






Welcome to your first lesson on the insatiable greed of big business. Get a lawyer and file suit. You'll get a check quickly. LoL
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

having off switches on the bilge pumps is nice to prevent accidental discharge in case of a leak or something, for instance during a filter change. things happen... being able to turn off the pumps while you mop up saves you from leaving a slick in the water.

BUT, they should have a safety cover on to make sure they're not accidentally turned off.

underwriters require surveys to make sure boats are up to standards, i really doubt a claim could be denied unless you can prove something was installed by a "pro".... this is ridiculous! define "pro" anyway... half of the "mechanics" out there know little about electrical system anyway and if you've been around boats long enough you have seen things done by "pros" that makes you shake your head in disbelief.






In a way, I think most boats do have an off switch by way of using the battery switch. My Bilge pumps have an Auto and On position only but when I turn the battery switch to off it kills power to everything. This IMO would be the best way to turn them off when servicing the boat so that there is less chance of the owner accidentally turning them off.
 
Ralph, my boat's ER bilge pump is direct to the batteries, as it is fully functional with all batteries off. This is not re-rigged--as such from the factory. Only the midship pump (shower & sink) is switched off with the main.
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

having off switches on the bilge pumps is nice to prevent accidental discharge in case of a leak or something, for instance during a filter change. things happen... being able to turn off the pumps while you mop up saves you from leaving a slick in the water.

BUT, they should have a safety cover on to make sure they're not accidentally turned off.

underwriters require surveys to make sure boats are up to standards, i really doubt a claim could be denied unless you can prove something was installed by a "pro".... this is ridiculous! define "pro" anyway... half of the "mechanics" out there know little about electrical system anyway and if you've been around boats long enough you have seen things done by "pros" that makes you shake your head in disbelief.






And if your not a pro and you screw up and the boat sinks, and they pin you, you are wrong. Consider someone installing a charger and the cables are not properly spec'd. The cables get hot enough to burn you (and stuff around them).
Pascal I'd rather send a less inclined person to a "pro" then have them do it themselves. Been there seen that, and sometimes it ain't the least bit pretty.
I tempered those remarks because this audience is quite diverse and I expect the people of experience to know better than those that have none. You could be boating 20 years and not know the least little thing about ensuring connections and wiring will hold up.
 
quote:

Originally posted by whitecrystal1

quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

having off switches on the bilge pumps is nice to prevent accidental discharge in case of a leak or something, for instance during a filter change. things happen... being able to turn off the pumps while you mop up saves you from leaving a slick in the water.

BUT, they should have a safety cover on to make sure they're not accidentally turned off.

underwriters require surveys to make sure boats are up to standards, i really doubt a claim could be denied unless you can prove something was installed by a "pro".... this is ridiculous! define "pro" anyway... half of the "mechanics" out there know little about electrical system anyway and if you've been around boats long enough you have seen things done by "pros" that makes you shake your head in disbelief.






In a way, I think most boats do have an off switch by way of using the battery switch. My Bilge pumps have an Auto and On position only but when I turn the battery switch to off it kills power to everything. This IMO would be the best way to turn them off when servicing the boat so that there is less chance of the owner accidentally turning them off.








i disagree :)

first, in 99.99% of cases the pumps are not shut down when the batt switches are off. If you leave the boat for a period of time, you may want to keep the batts off but obviously leave the pumps on.

now, let say you suddenly get a fuel leak (talking diesel obvoiously)... while underway, you may want to shut down the bilge pumps but still keep the boat going, or use the radio, or whatever. that's why it's good to have an off switch (easier than a fuse) which prevent the float switch from running the pump.

Dan, you have a valid point... yes, i've seen long time boaters and even active licensed captains who are totally clueless in the ER! i was just trying to say pros are not always any better...
 
"What's the point of paying for insurance if it's not there when you need it?"

I'm sure many will disagree with me but my observation has been that insurance is there to produce profits for the insurance company, its executives, and maybe its stockholders. Welcome to the "system"......!
 
quote:

Originally posted by sugilbert

Ralph, my boat's ER bilge pump is direct to the batteries, as it is fully functional with all batteries off. This is not re-rigged--as such from the factory. Only the midship pump (shower & sink) is switched off with the main.




The shower sump box is not considered a bilge pump. Most are 800gph and should be sealed to some degree. My mid ship pump is 2000gph and draws water from the hull not a box above the hull. Sure that pump should be on it's own breaker switch, in some boats it is wired to the head's breaker.
Bill
 
I'll point out the obvious, Bill, that my humble 26' is a tad smaller than your 40'. :)

Point being, that the main pump(s) should be always 'hot'.
 
Under a standard Yacht Policy, Owner's Negligence is a covered loss.
 
quote:

Originally posted by sugilbert

I'll point out the obvious, Bill, that my humble 26' is a tad smaller than your 40'. :)

Point being, that the main pump(s) should be always 'hot'.






well, the smaller the boat the more critical the bilge pumps are since you have less volume in the bilge and stgability will be affected with smaller amount of water.

on a 23 to 28 footer or so, you should have 2 x 2000 bilge pumps.
 
No---my sink & shower drain into a sealed housing.

I bit sorry I added that tidbit of info to my original post. It came back to bite me!
 
Back
Top