Pictures don't lie nor have an opinion . please no one take offense to my response i never want to see any boater hurt or a vessel damaged thats why i startad this thread with the intention that the hrcc could share knowledge for safty as well as good spots so please keep that in mind but it's hard to state a fact without it seeming that way . If you look at the grounded boats plain and simple they are in the wrong spot , run into any underwater object and of course that will happen , just DON'T blame it on the object for lack of knowledge , piloting or safe navagition skills. Would you for instance say the same of a skier going down a bare slope with one tree or rock in the middle of it then ,smacking right into it ,and blaming it on the tree or rock , and claiming the slope to dangerous ???? Iguess you would from what some are saying. if it wasn't equiptment failure , most would probably reckomend sking lessons "follow" ?. Entering bow line requires much less of a hazzard and manuvering then most would use to back into a slip espically if thier is wind , current , boats , ploes, ........ to contend with. thiers always risk when venturing out of a channel even with a chart and knowing how to use it thats basic knowledge but it seems like it must be stated here. Bow line is a piece of cake IT'S A STRAIGHT SHOT IN provided you know where to line -up which is the south end , if you follow it & stay as far to the south as your draft will comfortably allow and pass the sunken barge ( let me call it that for now .. more at end) jus turn to starboard ( YOU'R IN ! )whats so hard about that? i don't see how i've been proven wrong about that simple fact . it's preety wide seen boats squeese past each other there before, some of you seem to know a lot about it mabey you could help by giving pionts on shore to line up with or other info on approach . look at the size of some of the boats in there in your picturss looks like they made it with no problem . As far as the holding goes the picture doesn't prove anything look how many boats are on two hooks , i believe you when you say they drifted but thier is a lot of factors involved there, seen that happen at croton too. again you have to know what your doing . Some marinas at stony point where some of you (as well as myself) are docked have less water than bow line approach as well as other marinas on the river (I SEE LESS MUD RUNNING MY EXCAVATION CO.ON ARAINY DAY then trying to get near piermont for example) would you say they are dangerous. I 'm taking the time to post to help and enjoy chating with you all hoping we can share info. for the better of us all so try to keep that in mind not trying to be a know-it-all cause i sure as heck ain't thats for surei've hit so much crap floating in that river i'm thinking of changing the boat name to log basher, but facts are facts thats basically what i'm trying to state . about my pm i'm going to join i also would like to support the site was just feeling it out . Like i said before i've swam on the sunk barge thats what i recall i was told it was the config. of wood looks like it to me and there is a few bricks scattered on it( no suprise to anyone who knows the histiry of the area) but seems to be a old sunk rock barge but i really don't now could be a little of everything brick wall/ house / ....... maybe someone will chime in who knows ? hat would be cool....best whishes all look forward to hearing from you .......john f