aperrino, I suppose it's just like I said earlier, it's just about what fits your needs. I understand there was a point that no one wanted to be at Haverstraw because it was very poorly managed...that was before my time but I have heard pretty bad stuff. When I first went there 11 years ago there was a dock master/office manager named "MaryLou". Everyone who knows her will tell you she was one of a kind. The closest thing to her ability is Dolores in Catskill...but she's not running a 1,000+ marina. Since MaryLou left a few years ago it has just not been the same. Haverstraw is by no means a bad place to keep your boat, you will find some who think it is, but again, it is a preference. Haverstraw is very much a business, period. And huge!! As opposed to say PennyBridge where it is much smaller, privately owned & Rick, Steve & JD have more of a family mentality of their customers. Still a business but not a BUSINESS...if that makes sense. For you, with kids who love the pool, game room etc, plus the fact that it is calm water and you probably have less worries about you kids bouncing off the dock in rough water..it's perfect. For me, with limited time and a job that just seems to be getting more & more stressful..I am really looking for a place I can just relax. When the restaurant was closed, was not too bad, now that it's back open it is quite possible to walk almost 1/2 mile to get to my boat if I'm parked way out, made even more enjoyable if I'm carrying lots of stuff. Going back to my car is another event. People throwing up in parking lot, driving crazy looking for a parking spot, drunk drivers, couples pawing at each other, guys peeing in the bushes, broken bottles in parking lot and more fist fights than I care to remember. I also find it unnerving that I have not once this year seen the red Haverstraw Marina truck with the security guys ...and I have been there four times after 11:00pm when the gate was wide open...held open with a dock cart. Those are some of what bugs me...but hey, once it did not bother me at all!! It's all about where you are in your life and what your needs are. I will also say though, some of the people I have met at Haverstraw are now lifelong friends whether I am in boating or not, and I would really really miss a lot of people if I leave.
Haverstraw is by no means a "bad" place to boat, its a great marina and SO protected. Crystal & staff have always been great to us and they work their tails off there. For you it is perfect...for me, the enormity of it is growing old.